When people think of Niagara Falls, breathtaking waterfalls usually steal the spotlight, but there’s another side that food lovers can’t ignore—the incredible pizza scene.
This Best Pizza in Niagara Falls: A Complete Foodie Guide will take you through the city’s tastiest spots where flavors meet tradition.
From Western New York pizza classics to authentic Sicilian-style pizza, visitors will discover slices that tell stories of heritage and innovation.
Whether you crave a crisp coal-fired pizza, prefer the smoky touch of wood-fired pizza, or want to explore hidden gems in a charming Italian bakery Niagara Falls, your taste buds rewarded with every bite.
Here, pizza isn’t just food—it’s a celebration of culture, history, and flavor that makes Niagara Falls a true paradise for pizza lovers.
A Pizza-Lover’s Guide to Niagara Falls
Niagara Falls is filled with local pizzerias Niagara Falls that bring heritage, creativity, and flavor. Each eatery reflects the city’s deep Italian roots and adventurous food culture.
Some pies are served cold Sicilian-style, while others arrive crisp and bubbling straight from a coal oven burning at 1,000 degrees.
The local food scene shines because of its variety. Visitors can enjoy New York style pizza slices, try a pepperoni cup and char favorite, or taste a roast beef pizza twist inspired by a regional sandwich.
This guide is about more than restaurants; it’s about an entire flavor journey built for pizza lovers. Here, from classic recipes to creative twists, Niagara Falls pizzerias leave you with flavors as unforgettable as the falls themselves.
Niagara Falls isn’t just about pizza; it’s a destination packed with attractions, and checking Niagara Falls USA Travel Guide will help you plan meals around sightseeing.
DiCamillo Bakery: A Historic Taste of Niagara
The story of DiCamillo Bakery is legendary. This fourth-generation Italian bakery Niagara Falls has grown into a “mini-empire bakery” with four locations.
Its signature dish is Sicilian-style pizza, uniquely served cold Sicilian-style. The thick crust, rich toppings, and traditional preparation make it a perfect to-go option for a picnic near the Falls.
Toppings are varied. You can grab spinach and ricotta, broccoli, or a traditional pepperoni. For a sweet ending, their dessert biscotti has earned fame across Western New York.
Few places capture history and taste quite like DiCamillo. Visiting here is not just about eating; it’s an experience where the aroma, craftsmanship, and local heritage combine to make every bite unforgettable.
Goodfellas Pizzeria: Authentic Italian Flavors
Inside the Niagara Falls City Market sits Goodfellas Pizzeria, a true gem. This spot is known for its cup and char pepperoni slice, a Western New York pizza icon.
The pepperoni curls into tiny cups filled with flavor, creating little bowls of crisped edges and savory meat. For those who enjoy crunch, ask for your slice crispy crust well-baked.
Goodfellas is more than a quick stop. It is where visitors experience what locals eat daily. That mix of homestyle flavor and authenticity has made it a go-to spot for locals.
Every visit here feels personal, with aromas that invite you in and flavors that linger long after the last bite.
Woodcock Brothers Brewery: Pizza and Craft Beer Pairing
At Woodcock Brothers Brewery, pizza takes a creative turn. They combine tradition with innovation, serving wood-fired pizza and house-brewed beer in a lively atmosphere.
A highlight is their roast beef pizza twist, inspired by the region’s famous beef-on-weck sandwich. It’s something you won’t find elsewhere.
The pizza and beer pairing here is unmatched. Choose from stouts, ales, or lagers brewed on-site. Add a freshly baked pie from their wood-fired pizza oven, and you’ll see why this stop is on every foodie’s list.
A stop here feels more like a celebration — great pizza paired with local craft beer in a lively setting.
Joey’s Pizzeria: Local Favorite for Classic Pies
When it comes to classic pies, Joey’s Pizzeria delivers. This eatery proudly holds the Best Cheese Slice award from the Festival of Slice Niagara Falls in 2018.
Visitors love the casual atmosphere, while locals keep coming back for consistency. Weekends here are special because you’ll often hear live musicians on weekends, giving the place a fun, laid-back vibe.
Add wine, beer, and a hot pie, and it’s easy to see why Joey’s is considered a locals’ favorite pizza spot. Each slice shows why locals love Joey’s — simple, classic, and served in a fun, welcoming atmosphere.
La Hacienda Ristorante & Pizza: A Mexican-Italian Twist
Step back in time at La Hacienda Ristorante & Pizza, a retro-style Italian restaurant offering a mix of flavors.
Their New York style pizza slices come with a cornmeal bottom that creates a distinctive crunch. Alongside pies, the traditional Italian menu includes wings, pastas, and hearty dishes.
The old-school vibe continues with retro dining cocktails such as Grasshoppers and Harvey Wallbangers. Remember, it’s a cash-only restaurant, but don’t worry—there’s an ATM inside.
This spot mixes nostalgia with flavor — from the retro cocktails to the crispy pies, it feels like stepping back in time.
Gallo Coal Fire Kitchen: Signature Coal-Fired Pizzas
Few places connect food and history like Gallo Coal Fire Kitchen. Built on the site of Hustler’s Tavern, this restaurant honors Hustler’s Tavern cocktail history while serving coal-fired pizza.
Their coal oven burning at 1,000 degrees creates pies with a perfect charred crust and deep, smoky flavor.
The menu honors traditional Italian menu classics but with a modern spin. Each pizza is prepared with care, blending the old-world method with fresh ingredients.
Gallo captures both heritage and culinary craftsmanship. Visiting Gallo is more than a meal; it’s an experience where history, flavor, and skill come together, making every bite of coal-fired pizza memorable and unique.
Other Pizza Hotspots Worth Trying
While the main spots shine, there are more local pizzerias Niagara Falls worth noting. Mister B’s is loved for wings and pies, Michael’s Restaurant serves homestyle pizza with charm, and Just Pizza offers a wide range of toppings. Each brings its own flavor twist to the local scene.
Exploring these lesser-known gems adds variety to your trip. Pizza lovers can mix well-known favorites with new discoveries, ensuring every bite of Niagara Falls pizza is different yet unforgettable.
Trying these hidden spots allows you to experience the full spectrum of flavors, from traditional pies to creative modern twists, adding these hidden gems to your list makes the pizza scene in Niagara Falls feel even more exciting.
Tips for Enjoying the Best Pizza in Niagara Falls
To get the most out of your trip, keep a few insider tips in mind. Visit popular spots earlier in the evening to avoid long waits. If you prefer crunch, remember to ask for your pizza crispy crust well-baked.
Plan your meals around activities. Some pizzas, like DiCamillo’s, are a perfect to-go option for a picnic near the Falls.
Pair your pies with local beer or add a sweet ending with biscotti. These small touches will make your pizza journey in Niagara Falls even better.
Paying attention to these details ensures every bite is memorable, and it helps you fully appreciate the variety, flavors, and craftsmanship that make Niagara Falls pizza a must-try culinary experience.
If you’re planning more than just a food tour, staying at a nearby hotel like the Comfort Inn Fallsview makes it easy to enjoy both the pizza scene and the iconic waterfalls.
Conclusion
In Niagara Falls, pizza isn’t just a meal — it’s part of the city’s culture and character.
From the heritage of a mini-empire bakery to the excitement of retro dining cocktails and the heat of a coal oven burning at 1,000 degrees, every stop offers something unique. The city truly is a hidden paradise for drool-worthy pizza lovers.
If you’re planning a trip, make sure your taste buds explore as much as your eyes do. Niagara Falls may be famous for water, but the best pizza in Niagara Falls might just be the memory that lasts longest.
By exploring each pizzeria, you not only taste amazing pizza but also connect with the history, culture, and stories behind every slice, making your foodie adventure truly unforgettable.
FAQS
Q1: Where is the best place to get pizza in New York?
A: The best place is widely considered Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn for its classic, handcrafted pies.
Q2: What food is Niagara Falls, New York known for?
A: Niagara Falls, New York, is known for Western New York pizza, beef-on-weck sandwiches, and local Italian specialties.
Q3: What is the #1 pizzeria in the United States?
A: The #1 pizzeria in the U.S. is often Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana in New Haven, Connecticut.
Q4: Who has the best pizza in the world?
A: The best pizza in the world is frequently credited to Italy, especially Naples, for authentic Neapolitan pizza.
Q5: Which NY pizza won best in the world?
A: NY pizzas that have won “best in the world” titles include Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn and Lombardi’s in Manhattan.
I write about the world of luxury, from timeless style to premium living, inspiring readers to embrace elegance in everyday life.
